

6 Discontinued Foods Americans Still Miss — And How to Make Them at Home

Some childhood snacks were so good that even decades later, people still remember exactly how they tasted. And if you ever sneaked a cheesecake bar from the refrigerator or begged your parents for another box of your favorite candy, this list might bring back some delicious memories.
From frozen chocolate treats to crunchy peanut butter snacks, these six discontinued American favorites have inspired petitions, online communities, and countless attempts to recreate them. The best part? You don't necessarily need a time machine to experience some of those flavors again.

From frozen pudding pops to chocolate-covered peanut butter treats, six discontinued snacks continue to inspire nostalgic homemade recreations. | Source: AI-generated illustration
1. Jell-O Pudding Pops: The Frozen Treat That Disappeared Despite Its Popularity
There was something special about Jell-O Pudding Pops. Unlike traditional ice pops, which were usually fruity and icy, these frozen desserts offered a creamy, almost ice-cream-like texture that made them feel a little more indulgent.
They were especially memorable in the 1980s and 1990s, when chocolate and vanilla pudding pops became familiar freezer treats for American families. For many children, they were the perfect compromise between ordinary pudding and a frozen dessert.

Jell-O Pudding Pops offered a creamy frozen alternative to traditional fruit-flavored ice pops. | Source: AI-generated illustration
Why did Jell-O Pudding Pops disappear?
The history of the treat goes back several decades. According to The Daily Meal, General Foods developed the product in the late 1970s before it became a major part of the company's frozen dessert business.
By July 1981, the product was attracting enough attention that The New York Times published an article examining the company's ambitions for Pudding Pops.
But the treat's popularity came with a problem. The Daily Meal explains that production expenses and the economics of the frozen dessert business made the product difficult to sustain, even as consumers continued to enjoy it. A later version appeared under the Popsicle brand in the 2000s, but it eventually disappeared too. Fortunately, the company behind Jell-O still offers a way to make something remarkably similar at home.
How to make Jell-O Pudding Pops at home
You might expect recreating a discontinued frozen dessert to require special equipment or complicated ingredients. Surprisingly, Kraft Heinz's official Creamy Chocolate Jell-O Pudding Pops recipe calls for just three ingredients.
Creamy Chocolate Jell-O Pudding Pops
Prep time: 10 minutes | Freeze time: 4 hours | Servings: 6
Ingredients:
1 package (3.9 oz.) Jell-O Chocolate Fudge Instant Pudding
2 cups cold milk
1 cup thawed Cool Whip whipped topping
Instructions:
Whisk the pudding mix and milk together in a medium bowl for two minutes.
Gently stir in the whipped topping until completely combined.
Divide the mixture evenly among six small paper or plastic cups.
Insert a wooden popsicle stick or plastic spoon into the center of each cup.
Freeze for approximately four hours, or until firm.
Remove the pops from their cups and serve immediately.
Recipe source: Kraft Heinz.

Homemade pudding pops can be prepared with instant chocolate pudding, cold milk, and whipped topping before freezing. | Source: AI-generated illustration
And there's an even easier version for people who would rather skip mixing ingredients altogether. The company also shares a Frozen Pudding Pops recipe that involves inserting a wooden stick directly through the lid of a ready-made pudding cup and freezing it for five hours or overnight.
It may not recreate every detail of the original dessert, but it certainly captures the spirit of a simple childhood treat.
2. Philadelphia Cheesecake Snack Bars: The Dessert That Turned Refrigerators Into Hiding Places
Imagine finding a perfectly portioned slice of cheesecake waiting in the refrigerator. No restaurant reservation, no baking, and no need to share an entire cake.
For Americans who grew up in the late 1990s and early 2000s, Philadelphia Cheesecake Snack Bars offered exactly that experience.
These refrigerated desserts featured a graham cracker base, a creamy cheesecake layer, and a fruity topping finished with a delicate white chocolate drizzle. Strawberry and blueberry were among the familiar varieties, while chocolate chip and cappuccino versions were harder to find.

Philadelphia Cheesecake Snack Bars were remembered for their creamy filling, graham cracker base, and distinctive fruit-and-white-chocolate topping. | Source: AI-generated illustration
Why did the cheesecake bars disappear?
According to Allrecipes, the bars were discontinued in the early 2000s, although the precise reason remains unclear.
Production costs and manufacturing challenges have been suggested as possible explanations. But for devoted fans, the disappearance of the ready-to-eat dessert remains difficult to understand. Some people felt so strongly about the discontinued bars that they launched petitions calling for their return.
One Change.org petition described the treats as "delicious dessert bars that made you feel like you died and went to heaven." That might sound dramatic for a grocery-store dessert. But judging by the memories people continue to share, the bars weren't exactly an ordinary after-school snack.
The cheesecake bars people couldn't keep their hands off
Perhaps the funniest thing about Philadelphia Cheesecake Snack Bars is that some people didn't just love eating them — they apparently had to hide them from their own families.
In a nostalgic Reddit discussion, one user confessed, "My mom hid these in the back of the fridge but I always found them." Clearly, a secret hiding spot wasn't going to stand between a determined cheesecake fan and dessert. And judging by the other responses, this wasn't exactly an isolated household problem.

Reddit user u/bitchtrollfromhelll recalled finding the cheesecake bars even when their mother tried hiding them in the refrigerator. | Source: Reddit/bitchtrollfromhelll
For some parents, hiding the treats apparently wasn't enough. The only solution was to stop buying them altogether. Another user remembered, "My mom stopped buying them because I couldn't eat less than two at a time." It's a surprisingly relatable confession. After all, when a dessert comes in convenient individual portions, convincing yourself that a second one doesn't really count becomes dangerously easy.

Reddit user u/OfficerBarbier remembered that their mother stopped buying Philadelphia Cheesecake Snack Bars because one serving was never enough. | Source: Reddit/OfficerBarbier
And it seems those cheesecake bars had a reputation for inspiring a little childhood mischief. One summed up the experience perfectly: "These were the best snack to sneak behind your mom's back."
There's something wonderfully nostalgic about a dessert becoming the subject of a family-wide hiding game. Forget expensive restaurant cheesecakes — apparently, the real treasure was sitting somewhere behind the milk carton.
Other fans didn't need elaborate stories to express how much they missed the snack.
One wrote, "Those were delicious! Miss them!" Meanwhile, another user offered a slightly more dramatic reflection: "I could eat a whole box at a time. I should've while I had the chance. :'(" That last comment captures the strange regret that comes with discontinued favorites. Nobody tells you when you're buying your final box of something you'll spend the next twenty years wishing you could taste again.

Reddit user u/incredally07 shared a brief but enthusiastic reaction to the disappearance of Philadelphia Cheesecake Snack Bars. | Source: Reddit/incredally07

Reddit user u/strangep0wers jokingly regretted not eating more cheesecake bars before the product disappeared from stores. | Source: Reddit/strangep0wers
How to recreate Philadelphia Cheesecake Snack Bars at home
Here's where the story gets especially delicious. While the original refrigerated bars are gone, Philadelphia itself has published a Strawberry Cheesecake Bars recipe designed to evoke the familiar dessert. There's also an Allrecipes copycat version, which uses a graham cracker base, cream cheese filling, strawberry topping, and white chocolate drizzle.
For a homemade batch, around $12 is a possible rough ingredient-cost estimate if some pantry staples are already on hand. Buying full packages of every ingredient may cost considerably more, depending on the store and brands.
Philadelphia-Style Strawberry Cheesecake Bars
Prep time: 30 minutes | Total time: Approximately 1 hour 42 minutes, including chilling | Servings: 18
Ingredients
For the graham cracker base:
2/3 cup graham cracker crumbs
1/2 cup all-purpose flour
1/2 cup whole wheat flour
2 tablespoons butter
1/3 cup packed brown sugar
1 egg
For the cheesecake filling:
8 oz. Philadelphia cream cheese, softened
1/4 cup granulated sugar
2 tablespoons Jell-O Vanilla Instant Pudding Mix
2 tablespoons cornstarch
1 egg white
For the topping:
1/3 cup strawberry jam
1/3 cup white candy melts
Instructions
Combine the graham cracker crumbs with both types of flour.
Melt the butter and beat it with the brown sugar and egg. Gradually combine with the flour mixture.
Roll the dough into a 9-inch square and mark 18 rectangular portions. Refrigerate for 30 minutes.
Preheat the oven to 375°F.
Beat the cream cheese, sugar, pudding mix, cornstarch, and egg white together until combined.
Pipe the filling along the center of each dough rectangle, creating a shallow channel.
Add strawberry jam to the channels.
Bake for approximately 12 minutes, until the bases are slightly puffed and the filling is firm.
Cool completely and drizzle with melted white candy.
Refrigerate for at least 30 minutes before serving.
Recipe source: Philadelphia Kitchen / Kraft Heinz.

A homemade strawberry cheesecake bar reveals the creamy filling, graham cracker base, and fruit topping that made the discontinued dessert so memorable. | Source: AI-generated illustration
The company even recommends letting the finished bars soften in the refrigerator or freezer to bring their texture closer to that of the original snack. For readers who prefer watching someone make the dessert, a TikTok video by @lilypcrumbs offers another visual reference.
And if that first homemade bite brings back memories of sneaking snacks from the refrigerator, perhaps some traditions are worth keeping.
3. Planters P.B. Crisps: The Peanut-Shaped Treat Fans Refuse to Forget
Some snacks disappear and gradually fade from memory. Others develop such devoted followings that people spend decades trying to convince manufacturers to bring them back. Planters P.B. Crisps definitely belong in the second category.
Introduced in 1992, these peanut-shaped snacks featured a crunchy, cookie-like exterior filled with sweet peanut butter cream. They offered something different from ordinary peanut butter cookies: a light, hollow-style shell with a creamy surprise inside.

Planters P.B. Crisps combined a crunchy peanut-shaped shell with a sweet peanut butter filling. | Source: AI-generated illustration
Why did Planters stop making P.B. Crisps?
This time, the manufacturer has provided a direct explanation.
According to Planters' official FAQ, the product was discontinued in the 1990s because consumer demand was too low to keep it in production. The company also states that it currently has no plans to bring P.B. Crisps back. But try telling that to the people who still remember the snack more than 30 years later.

A nostalgic recreation of a 1990s living room, featuring a vintage television displaying a Planters P.B. Crisps-inspired advertisement — a reminder of the beloved peanut butter snack that disappeared from shelves decades ago. | Source: AI-generated illustration
An entire website, PBCrisps.com, is dedicated to the product and the campaign to revive it. The site includes historical information, photographs of the original packaging, advertising materials, and suggestions for contacting the manufacturer. Fans have even collected examples of the different varieties, which included the original peanut butter flavor, Chocolate Crisps, and PB&J Crisps.
The website's creator has encouraged other enthusiasts to share their memories and support efforts to return the product to store shelves. It's an impressive amount of dedication for a snack that once fit into the palm of a hand.
The commercial that made them memorable
Even the advertising was distinctive. A vintage Planters commercial introduced the snack through an animated sequence celebrating its peanut-shaped design and sweet filling. For viewers who remember watching the advertisement on television, seeing it again might be nearly as nostalgic as tasting the snack itself.
Can you still find anything similar?
One small company attempted to answer that question. Nutty & Nostalgic previously developed a product called 90's Crisps, inspired by the discontinued Planters snack. The independent P.B. Crisps fan website even documented its release in 2023. However, the original 90's Crisps listing no longer reliably displays the product, so its current availability should not be assumed.
For anyone interested in recreating the general flavor combination at home, there's a simpler approach: pair crisp, peanut-shaped or small butter cookies with a thick peanut butter filling. It won't reproduce the delicate structure of the original shells, but it can approximate the familiar combination of crunchy cookie and sweet peanut butter cream.
Quick Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwiches
Preparation: Approximately 10 minutes | Cooking: None, if using ready-made cookies
Ingredients:
12 small crisp butter or peanut-shaped cookies
1/4 cup creamy peanut butter
2 tablespoons powdered sugar, or to taste
A small pinch of salt, optional
Instructions:
Stir the peanut butter and powdered sugar together until thick and smooth.
Spread a little filling on the underside of six cookies.
Press the remaining cookies on top to create small sandwiches.
Chill briefly if a firmer filling is preferred.
Editor's note: This is a simple suggested substitute, not an official Planters recipe or a tested replica of the original P.B. Crisps.

Homemade peanut butter cookie sandwiches offer a simple way to revisit the sweet-and-crunchy combination associated with P.B. Crisps. | Source: AI-generated illustration
The shape and texture may be different, but sometimes a familiar flavor is enough to bring back a childhood memory.
4. Butterfinger BB's: The Tiny Chocolate Treat People Still Want Back
Imagine everything you loved about a Butterfinger bar, only in small, round pieces that were easy to eat by the handful. That was the appeal of Butterfinger BB's.
Introduced in the 1990s, the chocolate-covered candies featured the signature peanut butter-flavored crunch of a Butterfinger bar in a more convenient shape. For movie nights, lunchbox treats, and after-school snacks, they were an easy favorite.

Butterfinger BB's transformed the familiar chocolate-and-peanut-butter candy into small, round treats. | Source: AI-generated illustration
A candy with a memorable television connection
Butterfinger's advertising became closely associated with Bart Simpson from The Simpsons, helping introduce the candy to a generation of television viewers. The relationship was significant enough that Nestlé announced another Butterfinger campaign featuring Bart Simpson in 2013.
But the BB's version had its own appeal. Their small shape made them different from the traditional candy bar, even though the flavor was familiar. A Change.org petition called for the original candies to return, reflecting the frustration of fans who felt that later Butterfinger products weren't quite the same.
And in a Reddit nostalgia discussion, people continued to share their memories of the discontinued candy. For some fans, the appeal wasn't just the taste. It was the experience of eating something small, crunchy, and perfectly suited to sharing during a movie — assuming anyone actually wanted to share. The old advertisements also remain part of that nostalgia.
How to make Butterfinger-style bites at home
A homemade version might sound complicated, especially if you're trying to recreate the candy's unusual crunchy center. But Taste of Home offers a surprisingly simple recipe that uses just four ingredients. The unexpected secret is candy corn, which is melted and combined with peanut butter before being covered in chocolate.
Homemade Butterfinger Bites
Prep time: Approximately 30 minutes, plus setting time | Yield: About 48 pieces
Ingredients:
1 cup candy corn
2/3 cup peanut butter
1 cup semisweet chocolate chips
1 teaspoon coconut oil
Instructions:
Place the candy corn in a microwave-safe bowl and heat for 30 seconds.
Stir and continue heating in 15-second intervals until the candy corn melts.
Add peanut butter and heat for another 45–60 seconds, stirring periodically until smooth.
Shape the mixture into small balls, using approximately one teaspoon per piece.
Place the balls on waxed paper and allow them to firm up.
Melt the chocolate chips and coconut oil together until smooth.
Dip each peanut butter ball into the melted chocolate, letting any excess drip off.
Return the candies to waxed paper and leave them until the coating sets.

Homemade Butterfinger-inspired bites use melted candy corn and peanut butter beneath a chocolate coating. | Source: AI-generated illustration
The homemade pieces are expected to be softer and denser than the original flaky Butterfinger BB's. Still, the combination of chocolate and peanut butter makes them a tempting option for anyone craving a similar treat.
And perhaps the best part is that, unlike the discontinued candy, you can make another batch whenever you want.
5. 3D Doritos: The Puffy Chips That Made Snacking More Fun
Most tortilla chips are flat. It's such an ordinary feature that people rarely think about it. Then, in 1998, Doritos introduced a snack that looked like it had decided to break all the rules.
Doritos 3D featured puffed, hollow triangular shapes that offered a completely different experience from traditional tortilla chips. They were airy, crunchy, and covered in the familiar bold seasonings associated with the brand.

Doritos 3D stood out for their unusual puffed triangular shape and airy, crunchy texture. | Source: AI-generated illustration
Why did Doritos 3D disappear?
According to The Takeout, the original Doritos 3D debuted in 1998 and was discontinued in 2004. The precise reason has not been publicly established. Possible explanations include declining sales, shifting consumer preferences, and production expenses.
But unlike many discontinued snacks, Doritos 3D actually received a second chance. The product returned in late 2020 under the name Doritos 3D Crunch, with flavors including Spicy Ranch and Chili Cheese Nacho. And the relaunch wasn't exactly subtle.
The Super Bowl comeback with Matthew McConaughey
In 2021, the brand promoted the renewed three-dimensional snack with a Super Bowl commercial starring Matthew McConaughey. As Good Morning America reported, the advertisement showed the actor as an unusually flat, two-dimensional version of himself before discovering a way to return to his normal form.
It was a clever joke about the product's shape, and it brought renewed attention to a snack that many people associated with childhood.
But the comeback didn't last forever. According to The Takeout, the revived version also disappeared from American shelves around 2023. That means fans who miss the original are once again left searching for something with a similar crunch.
What can you eat instead of 3D Doritos?
If you're craving the airy, hollow texture rather than an exact match in flavor, one of the closest alternatives is Lay's Poppables White Cheddar. These potato-based snacks feature a light, lattice-like construction that produces an unusually airy crunch. They aren't shaped exactly like Doritos 3D, and their flavor profile is different. But they may appeal to people who miss the distinctive texture more than the specific seasoning.
A Quick 3D Doritos-Inspired Snack
Preparation: Approximately 5 minutes | Cooking: None
You'll need:
A bowl of plain puffed corn snacks
Nacho cheese or ranch-style snack seasoning
Optional chili powder for extra heat
Instructions:
Place the puffed corn snacks in a large bowl.
Sprinkle lightly with the seasoning of your choice.
Toss until the pieces are evenly coated.
Taste and adjust the seasoning before serving.
Editor's note: This is a flavor-inspired snack idea, not a tested replica of Doritos 3D. Its texture and shape will depend on the base snack chosen.

Modern puffed corn and potato snacks offer different ways to revisit the airy crunch associated with the original 3D Doritos. | Source: AI-generated illustration
It's not a perfect replacement. But for anyone who remembers how much fun those unusual triangular chips were, even a similar texture might bring back a few memories.
6. PB Max: The Chocolate-Peanut Butter Bar That Never Got Its Second Chance
Chocolate and peanut butter are one of America's most recognizable candy combinations. But in the late 1980s, Mars introduced a candy bar that took that pairing particularly seriously. PB Max combined a crunchy whole-grain cookie base with a generous layer of sweetened peanut butter, small cookie crumbles, and a milk chocolate coating. It was substantial, crunchy, and unmistakably peanut buttery.

PB Max combined milk chocolate, a crunchy cookie base, and a substantial layer of creamy peanut butter. | Source: AI-generated illustration
Why was PB Max discontinued?
The explanation associated with PB Max is almost as memorable as the candy itself. The bar was introduced around 1989 and disappeared by the mid-1990s, despite reportedly achieving substantial sales.
- JD and Usha Vance Welcome Their Fourth Child — and It's the Baby's Name That Has Everyone Talking
- 'Omg, Is That the Mountain?': Netizens Couldn't Believe It Was the Same Gregor Clegane From 'Game of Thrones' Following His Dramatic Weight Loss – Photos
- Madonna, 67, and Justin Bieber, 32, Are Reportedly at Odds Behind the Scenes of the World Cup Halftime Show — Chris Martin Is Caught in the Middle
As discussed in The Takeout and Joël Glenn Brenner's book The Emperors of Chocolate, accounts of the candy's demise have linked the decision to the Mars family's reported dislike of peanut butter. That explanation has become part of the product's legend, although it should be treated as an attributed historical account rather than a current official statement from Mars. Whatever the full explanation, PB Max has retained a surprisingly devoted following. A Change.org petition called for the candy bar's return, while vintage advertisements continue to remind people of its distinctive combination of peanut butter, cookies, and chocolate.
How to make PB Max at home
Here's the good news for anyone who still misses PB Max: a homemade version is entirely possible. Food blogger Karli Bitner developed a PB Max copycat recipe that recreates the candy's most important elements, including its crunchy cookie base, thick peanut butter filling, and milk chocolate coating. Her version even includes crunchy cookie crumbles over the peanut butter layer for an extra bit of texture.
Homemade PB Max Candy Bars
Prep time: Approximately 30 minutes | Bake time: About 20 minutes | Cooling time: At least 30 minutes, plus freezing and chocolate setting | Yield: 9 bars
Ingredients
For the cookie base and crumbles:
1/2 cup salted butter, softened
1/2 cup packed brown sugar
1 egg
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1 teaspoon baking powder
1 1/2 cups whole wheat flour
For the peanut butter filling:
2/3 cup creamy peanut butter
2/3 cup powdered sugar
For the chocolate coating:
2 bags (11.5 oz. each) milk chocolate chips
Instructions
Preheat the oven to 350°F.
Cream the butter and brown sugar together, then add the egg and vanilla.
Mix in the baking powder and whole wheat flour to create a firm cookie dough.
Shape and bake the cookie bases and additional pieces for crumbles, following the original recipe's directions.
Allow the cookies to cool completely.
Beat the peanut butter and powdered sugar together until smooth.
Spread a thick layer of filling over each cookie base.
Press the cookie crumbles into the peanut butter layer.
Freeze the assembled bars for approximately 15 minutes, or until firm.
Melt the milk chocolate and dip each bar until completely coated.
Place on parchment paper and let the coating set before serving.
Recipe source: Cooking With Karli.

A homemade PB Max-inspired bar reveals the layers of cookie, peanut butter, and milk chocolate that made the original candy distinctive. | Source: AI-generated illustration
For anyone who prefers watching the process, the Cooking With Karli recipe page also includes a video demonstration.
The finished version won't magically bring back the original wrapper or the experience of buying the candy at a convenience store decades ago.
But a crunchy cookie base, thick peanut butter filling, and generous chocolate coating might be enough to remind longtime fans why they loved PB Max in the first place.
The Snacks May Be Gone, but the Memories Aren't
There's something unusually powerful about the foods people loved as children. They aren't always expensive, sophisticated, or even particularly complicated, but they can become connected to moments that are impossible to recreate exactly.
A frozen pudding pop might bring back memories of summer afternoons. A cheesecake bar might remind someone of sneaking into the kitchen after school, while a handful of chocolate candies could transport them straight back to movie night.

Homemade versions of nostalgic snacks offer a delicious way to revisit the flavors many Americans remember from childhood. | Source: AI-generated illustration
Of course, homemade recreations aren't guaranteed to taste exactly like the originals. Ingredients change, recipes evolve, and sometimes the memory of a favorite snack becomes sweeter over time. But perhaps that isn't really the point.
The original products may have disappeared from grocery-store shelves, but their flavors have found a way to live on — through homemade recipes, old commercials, online petitions, and people who simply refuse to forget them.
And who knows? The next time you're standing in your kitchen with a bowl of chocolate pudding or a tray of peanut butter candies, you might discover that a little piece of childhood isn't quite as far away as you thought.









