Who Will Be the New Duke of York? Expert Weighs In as Prince Andrew Gives Up His Title

With Prince Andrew stepping back from his royal titles, the future of the Duke of York title remains uncertain, despite rising public interest and expert insight.

A royal reckoning years in the making has finally arrived, and this time, it bears the King's signature.

In a move as historic as it is humiliating, Prince Andrew has been publicly stripped of his right to use royal titles, including the disgraced Duke of York title, in a decision made after intimate consultation with King Charles III himself.

A Lifelong Title Now Tainted by Scandal

The King, according to sources, was consulted throughout the process and is said to be happy with the outcome.

The stunning announcement, issued on October 17, lands as the royal figure continues to face mounting scrutiny over his past ties to convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, and separate reports linking him to an alleged Chinese spy.

"In discussion with The King, and my immediate and wider family, we have concluded the continued accusations about me distract from the work of His Majesty and the Royal Family," Andrew said in a statement released by Buckingham Palace.

He added, "With His Majesty's agreement, we feel I must now go a step further. I will therefore no longer use my title or the honours which have been conferred upon me."

The change is effective immediately, according to royal sources. But while he may no longer call himself Duke of York, Andrew will still retain the title of "prince," which he holds by birth as the son of the late Queen Elizabeth II.

A King's Final Word on a Scandal-Scarred Brother

This isn't Andrew's first royal demotion, but it's his most definitive. Back in January 2022, the late Queen Elizabeth II took the first step in severing Andrew's royal ties, announcing he would be stripped of his military affiliations and patronages.

"With The Queen's approval and agreement, The Duke of York's military affiliations and Royal patronages have been returned to The Queen," Buckingham Palace stated at the time. "The Duke of York will continue not to undertake any public duties and is defending this case as a private citizen."

Now, nearly four years later, King Charles has finished what his mother started, erasing Andrew's public connection to the monarchy.

Exiled from Royal Duties, But Not from Royal Life

Though banned from official engagements, including the Royal Family's traditional Christmas celebrations, Andrew remains ensconced in Royal Lodge in Windsor, protected by a private tenancy agreement.

But even as he steps away from the spotlight, royal insiders warn this decision is more symbolic than substantial — and far from over.

"Removing his dukedom officially would legally require an act of Parliament and would be more complex than this immediate action," royal commentator Sharon Carpenter told E! News.

"For Andrew to be legally stripped of his dukedom before his death, it would require statutory action — a vote by Parliament," she shared. Which means: though the public may never hear him called Duke of York again, the title still legally belongs to him.

What Happens to the Duke of York Title Now?

Uncertainty reigns over the future of the once-revered Duke of York title. Sharon clarified that no one else will be granted the title — yet.

"It's possible that in the future someone may be granted Andrew's now former titles," Sharon explained. "But under current rules, a dukedom follows male-line succession. Andrew doesn't have a son, and it won't be passed to his daughters."

Instead, the title will eventually revert to the Crown upon Andrew's death, where the monarch may choose to reassign or retire it altogether — though any such move is unlikely to happen soon.

Sarah Ferguson's Courtesy Title Has Also Vanished

As Andrew falls, so too does his ex-wife's symbolic title. Sarah Ferguson, who famously retained the Duchess of York courtesy title following their 1996 divorce, will now be referred to simply as Sarah Ferguson.

Sources close to the duchess say she's unfazed by the change. "She will always support her former husband's decisions and do anything for the King. For her, this will not make a big difference," a family friend told Hello! magazine.

Still affectionately known as Fergie by the public, she has long used her maiden name in her media work.

Beatrice and Eugenie Untouched as Public Frenzy Takes Hold

Despite the unraveling of their father's status, Princess Beatrice and Princess Eugenie remain untouched. Both will continue to use their Her Royal Highness Princess titles.

Meanwhile, the internet has exploded with suggestions, speculation, and wishful thinking over who should become the next Duke of York whenever that time may come.

One Facebook follower insisted, "There won't be a new Duke of York for the simple reason that Andrew still holds the title and will continue to do so."

Others offered passionate suggestions. "Lady Louise, daughter of Prince Edward," one proposed. "One possibility for the new Duke of York could be Prince Louis, Prince William's third child," said another.

On Instagram, opinions were even more animated. "That would be Wonderful if Prince Louis got The Title of The Duke of York 😍," one wrote.

Another suggested, "Princess Anne's children are great. They should inherit the tittles [sic]." Others had different opinions, with one arguing, "Second son of the monarch… title goes to Prince Harry."

Adorable Prince Louis Emerges as Fan Favorite

But it's Prince Louis, the cheeky youngest son of Prince William and Princess Kate, who has emerged as the people's choice for the next Duke of York — even if his coronation is years, if not decades, away.

"He's already the coolest of the royals!" gushed one Instagram fan. "The new Duke of York," declared another. "This little guy will be Duke of York in the future," one commenter predicted.

Whether Louis, now just seven years old, will ever inherit the title remains uncertain — and will depend entirely on the King’s decision after Andrew's death.

The Crown's Most Tarnished Title Remains Frozen

For now, Buckingham Palace remains tight-lipped on any plans to reassign the title, and with no male heir in Andrew's line, the dukedom sits dormant, awaiting its fate.

The once-revered Duke of York title, now irreparably stained, remains in Andrew's possession — a graceless end to a disgraced chapter in royal history.

It may be years before anyone dares to wear it again.