

Mariah Carey's Unusual Walk in a New Video Has Fans Concerned — and an Expert Offers a Possible Explanation

Mariah Carey has spent decades proving that high heels are practically part of her DNA. But during a recent visit to Brazil, the Queen of Christmas had fans talking about something entirely different — and a new video only added to the conversation.

Mariah Carey | Source: Getty Images
For a singer famous for making even an ordinary sidewalk look like a red carpet, the footage was certainly unexpected. And while some viewers immediately expressed concern, others remembered something Carey had said about her feet years earlier.

Mariah Carey is spotted outside Il Tinello restaurant in New York City on September 7, 2026, just months before her walking videos from Brazil sparked an online debate. | Source: Getty Images
Mariah Carey's Famous Love Affair With High Heels
Let's be clear: Carey and high heels go way back. Whether attending glamorous events, stepping out for dinner, or performing for thousands of fans, the Grammy-winning singer has rarely missed an opportunity to add a little extra height to her look.
In fact, she's been joking about her unusual walking habits for years. During a 2024 interview recalled by RadarOnline, Carey laughed at one of the strangest rumors she'd heard about herself:
"One was that I can't walk by myself, or something like that, like I can't be upright and walk."

Mariah Carey makes another stylish appearance in New York City on April 18, 2026. The singer has long been associated with glamorous outfits and statement footwear. | Source: Getty Images
But here's the detail that makes her recent appearance particularly interesting. Back in 2007, Carey told The Times, as reported by IOL, that she struggled with flat shoes even as a child, explaining, "My babysitter used to laugh at me because when I was 12, I would always tiptoe." She added that wearing flats gave her blisters.
And apparently, that habit followed her into adulthood. During a November 2023 appearance on The Jennifer Hudson Show, Carey revealed that she didn't even own sneakers, explaining that they caused blisters on the backs of her feet.

Mariah Carey in heels during visiting The Great Wall of China. | Source: Instagram: @quelmomento
Remember that Great Wall of China moment? Carey caused quite a stir in September 2024 when she attempted to navigate the monument's steep steps in towering platform shoes, accompanied by members of her entourage.
She even laughed about her adventurous fashion choice afterward, joking on social media, "Someone should've warned me about heels." But what had once seemed like a classic Mariah moment became a rather different conversation when fans noticed her movements during a Las Vegas performance months later.
In February 2025, a video from Carey's Las Vegas residency attracted attention after she appeared to move stiffly while singing "Fantasy." While her backup dancers performed energetically around her, the singer took only a few measured steps before returning to the center of the stage.
Some viewers wondered whether she was feeling unwell, although others defended her relaxed performing style. Carey continued singing and smiling throughout the performance, and the short clip offered no explanation for her movements.
Fast-forward to November 2026, and Carey was back in the spotlight during a visit to São Paulo, Brazil, for her Christmas tour. According to Brazilian outlet Gshow, the singer arrived ahead of her November 17 concert and stopped to greet fans who had gathered outside her hotel.
But this time, it wasn't her spectacular voice or glamorous outfit that dominated the online conversation. Videos circulating in mid-November showed Carey taking noticeably cautious steps while holding an assistant's arm, prompting viewers to question what they were seeing.
As the footage spread, viewers offered very different interpretations. Some expressed genuine concern, while others pointed out that Carey was navigating an outdoor surface in high-heeled boots — hardly the easiest combination, especially in wet weather.
One viewer defended the singer, writing, "It looks like she's limping. She could've hurt her ankle or something." Others continued to question whether the careful steps suggested something more.

One Instagram user suggested Carey appeared to be limping, wondering whether an ankle injury might explain her cautious movements. | Source: Instagram/@@iamkiaramonique_
Other viewers had similar questions. "Knee pain or smthg," wrote an Instagram user, offering another possible explanation for the singer's careful steps, though there was no confirmation of any injury.
But not everyone was eager to jump to conclusions. Some fans urged others to remember that even the biggest stars can experience ordinary physical discomfort — and one commenter expressed that sentiment particularly warmly: "Her knees might be hurting . She is human ppl❤️"

Another Instagram commenter urged viewers to show compassion for Carey, reminding others that the singer is human, too. | Source: Instagram/@introducing_the_hardline
And just when the conversation seemed to be going in circles, another appearance gave fans an entirely new detail to discuss. Carey returned to greet supporters outside her São Paulo hotel, dressed in black, with her signature sunglasses and an unusually practical addition to her outfit.
Was it simply a change of style, an attempt to feel more comfortable, or something else entirely? Whatever the reason, the new footage offered an interesting contrast to the earlier clips — and fans were quick to notice.
And there it was — Mariah Carey without her trademark towering heels. According to Page Six, the singer stepped out on November 13 wearing a black minidress, tights, and flat Gucci loafers, a significant departure from the high-heeled Gucci boots she'd worn previously.
The newer footage, described by Parade, appeared to show Carey moving more comfortably across the dry pavement without requiring the same assistance. For some fans, however, the biggest surprise was simply seeing their favorite diva in flat shoes at all. X user seemed particularly shocked by the singer's footwear, commenting, "Wow something is up bc Maria Carey ALWAYS wears hills she never goes with flats I'm shocked." And considering how rarely Carey is seen without her signature towering heels, it's easy to understand the surprise. Still, an unexpected pair of flats doesn't necessarily mean something is wrong with her health.

One X user expressed disbelief at seeing Carey in flat shoes, pointing out how closely the singer has been associated with high heels throughout her career. | Source: X/@CeeWik58274
And the surprise didn't stop there. "Wearing flats? 😱" wrote X user, while another asked, "This is Mariah? In those shoes?!" Clearly, seeing the diva without her signature heels was almost as surprising to some fans as the walking footage itself.
Yet while the unexpected footwear sparked plenty of speculation, it offered no definite answers about Carey's health. The earlier videos had prompted HELLO! to consult movement specialist Nathalie Clough, who discussed how footwear, balance, and physical discomfort can influence the way someone walks.

Mariah Carey steps out in a black minidress, tights, and Gucci flats, swapping her signature high heels for a more comfortable look while surrounded by security in Brazil. | Source: Instagram/@etalkctv
The comments quickly took on a lighter tone. As Parade reported, one social media user joked, "Mariah wearing flat shoes is an economic indicator," while another defended her choice to prioritize comfort. Still, the earlier footage had raised enough questions for HELLO! to consult movement specialist Nathalie Clough, a Pilates instructor and founder of LifeBody studio in London. Her explanation suggested that the way someone walks can be influenced by several factors — not necessarily an obvious lack of flexibility.

Mariah Carey walks past fans outside her hotel in Brazil, showing off her unexpected choice of flat shoes after earlier footage of her cautious steps sparked concern online. | Source: Instagram/@etalkctv
Clough explained that people sometimes change the way they walk in response to pain or instability, shortening their stride or adjusting their balance. However, she also emphasized that walking downhill in high heels can significantly affect a person's movement and that no medical conclusions should be drawn from a short video. And that's an important distinction, especially when millions of people are watching the same few seconds of footage. As Clough explained to HELLO!, the spine, pelvis, hips, and feet all work together when someone walks, meaning that discomfort in one area can affect the entire movement.
But does that mean something is necessarily wrong with Carey? Not at all. Clough stressed that understanding the reason behind restricted movement matters more than simply trying to improve flexibility, and that a short video cannot establish whether someone is experiencing a medical problem.
And there's another part of the story that shouldn't be overlooked. Despite the attention surrounding her movements, Carey continued making time for the people who had gathered to see her, smiling for photographs and greeting supporters outside her hotel.
- Nicole Kidman Catches Eyes in a Chanel Tutu at the 2026 LACMA Art+Film Gala — and Fans Can't Stop Zooming In on One Detail — Photos
- Rihanna Steps Out in Paris in a Chic All-Black Look — and Her Outing Is Sparking Chatter Online — Video
- Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Step Out for His 37th Birthday Dinner in Coordinated All-Black Looks — Photos
According to Brazilian outlet Gshow, the singer happily interacted with fans during her November 13 appearance, offering autographs and friendly waves. Whatever viewers thought about her walking, the photographs also captured a star enjoying a warm welcome from her Brazilian audience.
And while the internet was busy debating her shoes, Carey had something much bigger on her schedule. The singer was preparing to bring her Christmas Time production to São Paulo, complete with festive decorations, dancers, and a collection of songs that have made her a holiday-season icon.
In fact, preparations continued well into the night. According to UOL, fans staying near the concert venue heard Carey rehearsing "I Want to Know What Love Is" during a late-night soundcheck on November 17. Even before she took the stage, the singer was giving Brazilian fans something else to talk about.
Meanwhile, Carey's performances continued. She took the stage in São Paulo on November 17, where Folha de S.Paulo reported that she entertained the audience with her familiar Christmas songs and a string of beloved hits.
And perhaps that's worth remembering amid all the online speculation. The woman who has spent decades dazzling audiences in sky-high heels is also allowed to choose comfortable shoes, take a cautious step, or accept a helping hand without those moments becoming a diagnosis.
Whether her recent movements reflect footwear, surroundings, personal comfort, or something else remains unknown. But one thing is certain: even after all these years, Mariah Carey can still get the entire internet talking — sometimes without singing a single note.
And perhaps the real surprise isn't that Carey was spotted wearing flats, but how quickly a simple change of shoes turned into a worldwide conversation. After all, behind the dazzling gowns, sky-high heels, and larger-than-life diva persona is a woman who doesn't always have to be picture-perfect. And if there's one thing Mariah has earned after decades in the spotlight, it's the freedom to take life at her own pace — one step at a time.









