'Doesn't Even Look Like Her': Users React to Sabrina Carpenter's New Cover for Vogue

The singer and actress's latest Vogue cover has sparked a heated debate among fans, with many questioning the heavy editing of her appearance and others defending her artistic expression.

Sabrina Carpenter graced the cover of Vogue's March 2025 issue, marking a major milestone in her career. The rising fashion icon took on a vintage and daring look for the cover shoot. However, rather than unanimous praise, the internet was soon flooded with comments debating whether the image truly resembled the pop star.

Carpenter, now 25, has long been a dominant force in music and acting in the past few years. Her career began on the Disney Channel but quickly transitioned into mainstream music, and released six studio albums so far.

Her most recent record, "Short n' Sweet," debuted at number one on the Billboard 200 chart in September 2024 and earned platinum certification.

Her songs blending disco, country, R&B, and folk, showcased Carpenter's sharp writing and playful personality. Furthermore, her growing fan base has embraced her ultra-feminine aesthetic, a style often described as both nostalgic and provocative.

Vogue's March 2025 cover is the perfect example of her current fashion choices, except with a little more drama and bigger blonde curls. The magazine's article highlighted the singer's ability to seamlessly transition between different personas in her music and wardrobe.

While Carpenter has previously stated that her "Short n' Sweet" era is not an alter ego but an amplified version of herself, this cover shoot seemed to take that concept to the next level.

That may be why many netizens had differing opinions about her appearance. One fan stated, "That doesn't even look like her…" Meanwhile, another echoed the sentiment, "She doesn't look like Sabrina Carpenter 😮 I would always want people to look at a photograph of me and it's a better version of me [sic]."

Others commented on the photograph's retouching. One wrote, "Too much editing on her face, doesn't look like her [sic]." Another netizen added, "Heavily edited, that's why I don't like it [sic]."

A user on X added, "A lot of photo shop. It's a beautiful picture but doesn't look like Sabrina. She's talented and I like her music, but it will be interesting to see if she has staying power and continue to develop her range [sic]."

Despite the criticism, many fans rallied behind Carpenter to praise the artistic direction of the cover. One user compared her look to a music legend, "For sec I thought it was Madonna [sic]." Another added, "Sabrina channeling Madonna who was channeling Marilyn."

Some appreciated the cover for its original portrayal, with a netizen commenting, "Actually is kind of refreshing to see a young, beautiful and what appears to me a healthy young woman." Others celebrated the singer's appearance with comments like, "Oh Sabrina you ate that" and "She is the icon 👏."

A particularly passionate fan defended the cover, "Why are yall acting like this, she looks fine and like herself. God forbid she has a diff hairstyle or makeup for one time??? Like god??? She's an artist. You're not on Vogue, she is! Let's be happy for her. This is an insane accomplishment [sic]."

Carpenter has continuously reinvented herself throughout her career, proving her versatility in music and fashion. Whether loved or criticized, the attention surrounding the shoot solidifies her status as one of the most talked-about young stars in the industry today.